I may be opening a serious can of worms by writing this, but I felt that it was important for me to get my thoughts out. First of all, my feelings should not make me into a [pick a label]. These are just my thoughts, but I am prepared to write about why I have them.
Let me make something perfectly clear; I will not insult anyone who views things differently than me, which is probably what has bothered me the most about tonight’s announcement. I have been called a lot of names by a lot of people because I am not happy about them naming a woman as the next Doctor. I have my reasoning behind it, but much of it is not about feminism, but rather about writing and continuity.
I accept it, sure, but I do so on my own terms and not on anyone else’s. To me, this has only come across as an experiment to see if something completely different is going to work. Yes, that sounds rather jaded, but that’s my initial reaction on it, and I would never insult the actress they selected, but I will not be forking over money to watch the episodes the moment they are released. When they come out on tv here, then I will probably watch them translated in German, but I’m not really feeling myself inclined to go out and buy the episode downloads for 30+€ only because it’s ‘Doctor Who’.
Let me just say straight up, I am not a misogynist, I am myself female and I believe in feminism. I just don’t think naming a female Doctor is necessarily about women’s rights or liberation. What I do think about are things like reproductive rights, girls being allowed an education, LGBT rights, equal pay for equal work, and women being able to take on the same jobs as men. That is what feminism is to me, not whether or not a woman is cast in an iconic television series. If people are going to complain about a woman being cast as the Doctor and tell objectors that they are ‘sexist’ for feeling what they feel, then those so called ‘feminists’ have lost track on what is really important to women. I don’t think the women who are out there fighting on the front lines for the real issues really give a care that a woman was cast in Doctor Who. In fact, I would be willing to bet that that is the last thing on their mind.
People are asking why it is that I am not happy about it and I will outline that right here. I’m not outwardly opposed to a woman being cast as the Doctor, but I do have reservations about it. The main reservation I have is at the very beginning of the series, there was a character named Susan Foreman who was the Doctor’s granddaughter. Susan went about calling the Doctor ‘Grandfather’ throughout her tenure on the show. This was something that was firmly established as the Doctor was this girl’s family. Later, she showed up in Big Finish audios as an older woman with a son, and Paul McGann was called ‘Grandfather’ even though the actor is younger than the actress playing Susan. That didn’t feel weird to me at all given what I knew about the characters. The change in gender may, in fact, confuse some if they are looking at things from the very beginning of the series. I mean 1963 NOT 2005. I know a lot of people couldn’t care less about the history and the Doctor’s place in it, but this is something that may come up with classic fans and it may also explain why it is some of us are dragging our feet about a woman taking on the role.
To sort of help that along, maybe what needs to happen with regards to Susan is that sense of awareness for her character that her grandfather could regenerate into a woman. That was never established in the early days of Doctor Who because the question was never really raised and the significance of it was not present back then.
Today, I think that it would be a nice way to acknowledge the classic fans who are overall hesitant about this particular change. I am doubtful that the modern day political correct people in charge are going to be willing to do that, though. It is sad state of affairs to see a fandom being ripped apart over this, but I’ve been in fandoms before and have quit them when the feel of them turned sour, so this is not something out of the ordinary, it does happen. The reality is this: I will not stay in a place where people call me nasty names for having an opinion or world view that is different from their own.
The simple act of bringing back Carole Ann Ford could be a way to acknowledge this change and have her bring all of this into alignment with the Doctor’s history. As it currently stands, I am sitting here with my reservations about the show and wondering if this annoncement was done as a way to shock everyone in the fandom and force us to take sides on the issue. To me that is the underlying result and whether the powers that be like it or not, this is the result of their decision.
The bottom line for me is this: If the people who are gung ho about a woman Doctor simply decide to write all of the classic fans off as just ‘misogynist bigots’, then they will have a hard time bringing those fans back into the show or the fandom. No one likes to be called names and I went through enough of that last year when voting in a blasted election. I am not going to subject myself to this rubbish again over a bloody television show.
The people who wanted a woman Doctor got what they wanted, but some of them are still resorting to name calling, which is a crying shame. As I posted above, there are some of us that do have reservations about it, but it’s not about what you think. So before you decide to call people names and stereotype us, maybe you need to adapt the same sort of understanding and acceptance that you’re demanding from us. Tolerance is a two-way street and it should come from all sides, not just one.